MinecraftRanking

1.8 vs 1.9 PvP Explained: What Changed and Why Players Still Argue

By the MinecraftRanking team · · Live numbers from our own server pings

The 1.9 Combat Update in 2016 changed Minecraft PvP more than any update before or since. Here is how 1.8 and 1.9+ combat differ, why so many PvP servers still run 1.8 rules, and which style suits you.

Mention "1.8 vs 1.9" to a Minecraft PvP player and you will get a strong opinion. On February 29, 2016, Mojang released Java Edition 1.9, the Combat Update, and it rewrote how fighting works. Ten years later the PvP community is still split between the two systems. Here is what actually changed.

How 1.8 PvP works

In 1.8 and earlier, there is no cooldown on attacks. Every hit does full damage, however quickly you click, so the faster and more accurately you click, the more damage you deal. That shapes everything about the style:

Fights are fast and aggressive. It is the style that grew up on Survival Games, KitPvP and HCF servers in the early 2010s.

What 1.9 changed

The Combat Update added a whole new layer:

1.9 also added the Elytra and let end crystals be placed on obsidian and bedrock, which much later became the core of crystal PvP. The same update removed the crafting recipe for enchanted golden apples, so they can only be found as loot, not made.

Why the community split

Many competitive players felt the cooldown slowed combat down and took away the skill they had spent years building. Click speed and combos stopped mattering as much, and fights became about timing each swing. Others liked that 1.9 made combat less about raw clicking and more about weapon choice, positioning and shields.

The result was a lasting split. A large part of the PvP scene, especially practice servers, HCF and classic KitPvP, kept playing with 1.8 rules. Modern survival and SMP servers moved on with the game. Many servers today run 1.8-style combat on newer versions, or let players join from any version while keeping the old rules.

Did Mojang try to fix it?

Yes. Starting in June 2019, Mojang released a series of experimental Combat Tests, led at first by Jens "Jeb" Bergensten. They kept a cooldown but changed reach, sweeping, shields and hunger. The last test came out in August 2020, and the project has been on hiatus since. None of those changes became the main game's combat system.

PvP on our list right now

Measured by our pinger this hour. Big networks list many modes, so player totals include everyone on those networks.

Which should you play?

Our best PvP servers and best KitPvP servers guides rank servers by real player numbers. For the history behind the 1.8 crowd, see What happened to MCSG? and What is HCF?

Our pick

Where to play: EvadeCraft

Want PvP with a reason behind it? EvadeCraft mixes quick fights with long-term raiding, on Java and Bedrock.

mc.evadecraft.com Vote
  • Monthly payouts: $1,550 in prizes every month: $550 in real cash plus $1,000 in store credit, for Factions and Skyblock players.
  • KitPvP: straight into the action, no grind.
  • Factions: monthly maps ending on the last day of each month at 8 PM Eastern, with base raids, KOTH, Outposts and Warden fights.
  • Easy to join: Java and Bedrock (1.10 - 26.3), no mods or downloads.
  • Active: 136 players on average over the last 7 days.

EvadeCraft is run by the team behind MinecraftRanking, so take our pick with that in mind. Every number in this article that is not about EvadeCraft comes from our own server pings.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between 1.8 and 1.9 PvP?

In 1.8 there is no attack cooldown, so clicking faster lands more hits and sword blocking reduces damage. From 1.9 on, each weapon has an attack cooldown, hits before it recharges do less damage, and shields, the off-hand slot and sweep attacks were added.

Why do PvP servers still use 1.8?

Much of the competitive PvP community preferred 1.8's fast, click-based combat and stayed with it. Many servers keep 1.8 combat rules while letting players join from newer versions.

Is 1.9 PvP harder than 1.8?

They test different skills. 1.8 rewards click speed, aim and combos. 1.9+ rewards timing, spacing, shield and axe use, and item choice. Neither is simply harder.