MinecraftRanking

How Greed Killed InsanityCraft, CosmicPvP and UniverseMC

By the MinecraftRanking team · · Live numbers from our own server pings

InsanityCraft, CosmicPvP and UniverseMC were three of the biggest names in Minecraft Factions. Each one was packed, and each one put money ahead of players. Here is how that played out, and what to look for in a server now.

InsanityCraft, CosmicPvP and UniverseMC were not small servers that never got going. Each of them had packed map launches, big factions and a real place in a lot of players' memories. Each of them also ended up in the same place: shrinking, emptying out, and in two cases gone entirely.

Factions as a whole has got smaller over the years, but that is not the full story. These servers had the players. In our view, what they did with them is what finished them off. The opinions in this article are ours, from years of playing Factions, including on these servers.

Measured by our pinger this hour across every listed server with the Factions tag. Networks that run several modes count in full here. Factions activity is down 35% on the week before.

The rules every server agrees to

It helps to know what the rules actually say, because all three servers ran into them.

Minecraft's audience includes a huge number of children. Rules like these exist because random paid rewards and pay-to-win stores land hardest on young players spending money they do not fully understand. We explain the background in Minecraft pay-to-win explained.

InsanityCraft: broken items, then expiring reclaims

InsanityCraft Factions was popping at its height. In our view, three things wore it down:

  1. Overpowered items sold in the store. New items that were too strong for the game arrived map after map, and the way to get them was to pay. Free players could not compete.
  2. Paid random crates sold to a young audience, the exact kind of chance-based purchase both Mojang and Tebex rule against.
  3. Staff who did not play Factions. Good players were banned as often as cheaters, while blatant hackers lasted for days.

Then came the move that many players will never forgive. For years, InsanityCraft's reclaim system let players get back what they had paid for at the start of every map, and players spent heavily on the idea that those purchases were permanent. With the server struggling to keep players, reclaims were changed to expire, with no input from the community, long after most of those purchases could be disputed.

The same approach was repeated on InsanityCraft's Skyblock and Survival servers: broken items released to drive sales, and players left to deal with the result. The full story is in What happened to InsanityCraft Factions?

CosmicPvP: the biggest name, the same habits

Cosmic was the biggest name Factions ever had, co-founded by two of the most famous Minecraft YouTubers of their time. It had everything a server could want: an audience, a talented development team and, at its peak, more players than most networks ever see.

In our view, it also set the template for everything wrong with big Factions servers. Its store leaned heavily on gameplay advantages and random paid rewards, at a scale few servers matched, and the game was shaped around selling them. Rules about pay-to-win and gambling were treated as something to work around rather than follow. Cosmic's original Factions and Prison servers closed in 2023. For the timeline and what is still running, read What happened to CosmicPvP?

UniverseMC: made the money, then walked away

UniverseMC was never really about Factions. In our experience, its growth leaned on bot accounts spamming adverts into other servers' chats, rather than on players recommending it. The money it made did not go back into legitimate advertising or a better game, and player feedback was ignored map after map.

By the end it was close to empty and barely earning anything. There was no announcement and no farewell map. In our view, the owner had made what they set out to make, lost interest and shut it down, even though the server meant a great deal to the people who played there. More in What happened to UniverseMC Factions?

The pattern

Put the three side by side and the same story repeats:

Players are not stupid. They notice when a server stops being fair, and they leave. That, more than anything, is why so many people now ask whether Factions is dead.

What to look for in a Factions server now

Our best Factions servers ranking is built from our own player-count pings, or browse every Factions server on our list.

Our pick

Where to play: EvadeCraft

If you miss the Factions these servers used to be, EvadeCraft is our pick for that old-school experience, run by people who actually play Factions.

mc.evadecraft.com Vote
  • Monthly payouts: $1,550 in prizes every month: $550 in real cash plus $1,000 in store credit, for Factions and Skyblock players.
  • Monthly maps: every Factions map ends on the last day of the month at 8 PM Eastern, then everyone starts fresh.
  • Real Factions: land claims, base raids, KOTH, Outposts and Warden fights.
  • More on the network: Skyblock with generators, missions and island upgrades, plus KitPvP and Farm King.
  • Easy to join: Java and Bedrock (1.10 - 26.3), no mods or downloads.
  • Active: 136 players on average over the last 7 days.

EvadeCraft is run by the team behind MinecraftRanking, so take our pick with that in mind. Every number in this article that is not about EvadeCraft comes from our own server pings.

More reading: How to play Factions · How to start a faction · What happened to Mineplex?

Frequently asked questions

Why do big Minecraft Factions servers die?

Factions as a whole has shrunk, but the biggest servers mostly died from their own choices: selling items that decide fights, selling random paid crates, ignoring player feedback and not reinvesting in the server. Players leave when the game stops being fair.

Is it against the rules for Minecraft servers to sell pay-to-win items?

Mojang's usage guidelines only allow servers to sell things that affect gameplay if they do not ruin other players' experience or give a competitive advantage, and they say everything sold must be suitable for all ages, naming gambling as an example of what is not.

Where can I find old-school Factions now?

Look for monthly maps, staff who play Factions and a store that does not decide fights. Our pick is EvadeCraft, which starts a new Factions map every month and pays out $550 in cash plus $1,000 in store credit every month.