What Happened to InsanityCraft Factions? What Really Killed It
By the MinecraftRanking team · · Live numbers from our own server pings
InsanityCraft Factions was once packed. Then came pay-to-win items, paid crates, hackers and finally reclaims that suddenly expired. Here is what killed it, and where Factions players can go now.
InsanityCraft Factions used to be busy. Map launches were full, the factions were big and there was always a fight somewhere. If you are coming back after a few years and wondering where all of that went, the short answer is that the people running it cared far more about the store than about Factions.
This is the longer answer. It is written from the experience of Factions players who were there, including people on our team, and the opinions in it are ours.
A staff team that did not play Factions
Factions is a hard mode to run. Staff need to know how raids work, what a fair cannon looks like, which movement is skill and which is a hack client. At InsanityCraft, in our experience, the team was largely made up of people who were not Factions players, and new staff were recruited the same way.
That showed up everywhere, but nowhere more than in bans:
- Good players got banned. A skilled player with clean aim was about as likely to be banned as an actual cheater, because staff could not tell the difference.
- Blatant hackers stayed. Players flying, killing through walls and auto-clicking could last for days before anyone acted.
- Trust collapsed. When legitimate players are punished and cheaters are not, the legitimate players leave first. That is exactly the wrong half of your player base to lose.
If you are on a server like that now, our guide to reporting a hacker explains how to make a report hard to ignore.
Broken items, sold in the store
The bigger problem was what went into the store. Map after map, new items were released that were simply too strong for the game, and the way to get them was to pay. Free players found themselves fighting people with gear they had no realistic way to match. For anyone not spending, the experience was miserable.
Mojang's own rules for servers are clear on this. The Minecraft Usage Guidelines only allow servers to sell entitlements that affect gameplay if they do not ruin other players' experience or give a competitive advantage. In our view, overpowered items that decide fights broke that rule outright. We explain the rule in more detail in Minecraft pay-to-win explained.
Paid crates, aimed at kids
Alongside the items came paid crates: you spend real money on a key and get a random reward. That is gambling in everything but name, and Minecraft's audience includes a huge number of children.
- Mojang's guidelines say everything a server sells must be suitable for audiences of all ages, and they name gambling as an example of what is not.
- Tebex, the store platform most Minecraft servers use, bans selling anything where the reward is based on chance, and names "lootboxes" and similar mechanics under other names in its Acceptable Use Policy.
In our view, selling random paid crates to a young audience went against both. We cover how crates work, and what fair ones look like, in What are crates on Minecraft servers?
Reclaims: sold as permanent, then made to expire
This is the part that hurt the most. InsanityCraft used a reclaim system: buy an item or perk, and you could claim it again at the start of every new map. For years that was the selling point. Players were told, in effect, that what they bought was theirs to keep, and some spent thousands of dollars, in a few cases tens of thousands, on that promise.
Then, with no input from the community, reclaims were changed to expire.
Think about what that means. Items that broke the game were sold, the money was collected, and once the server was struggling to keep players, the answer was to take away what everyone had paid for. Most card payments can only be disputed within a few months of the purchase, so by the time players felt the change, many of those purchases were long past the point where a chargeback was possible. Whether or not that timing was planned, it meant the money stayed where it was and the players were left with nothing.
The result
Put it all together and the decline is no mystery. Free players were priced out, legitimate players were banned or driven off by cheaters, and the players who had spent the most were told their purchases no longer counted. A Factions server cannot survive losing all three groups at once.
The same pattern played out on other big Factions networks. We compare them in How greed killed InsanityCraft, CosmicPvP and UniverseMC, and you can see how the mode is doing overall in Is Minecraft Factions dead?
Where should InsanityCraft players go now?
If you miss Factions the way it used to feel, look for a server that does the opposite of everything above:
- Staff who play Factions and can tell skill from cheating.
- A store that does not decide fights. Nothing you can buy should be stronger than what you can earn.
- Fresh maps on a clear schedule, so everyone starts equal.
- Clear, honest rules on what you are buying and how long it lasts.
Our best Factions servers ranking is built from our own player-count pings, or browse every Factions server on our list.
Our pick
Where to play: EvadeCraft
If you want the old Factions experience back, EvadeCraft is our pick: Factions run by people who actually play Factions, with a fresh map every month.
mc.evadecraft.com Vote- Monthly payouts: $1,550 in prizes every month: $550 in real cash plus $1,000 in store credit, for Factions and Skyblock players.
- Monthly maps: every Factions map ends on the last day of the month at 8 PM Eastern, then everyone starts fresh.
- Real Factions: land claims, base raids, KOTH, Outposts and Warden fights.
- More on the network: Skyblock with generators, missions and island upgrades, plus KitPvP and Farm King.
- Easy to join: Java and Bedrock (1.10 - 26.3), no mods or downloads.
- Active: 136 players on average over the last 7 days.
EvadeCraft is run by the team behind MinecraftRanking, so take our pick with that in mind. Every number in this article that is not about EvadeCraft comes from our own server pings.
More reading: What happened to UniverseMC? · What happened to CosmicPvP? · How to play Factions
Frequently asked questions
What happened to InsanityCraft Factions?
In our view it was run into the ground by money-first decisions: overpowered items sold in the store, paid random crates, weak anti-cheat enforcement by staff who did not play Factions, and finally a change that made the reclaims players had paid for expire.
What were InsanityCraft reclaims?
Reclaims let players get back the paid items and perks they had bought at the start of every new map. For years players treated them as permanent, which is why so many spent large amounts on them. Then reclaims were changed to expire.
Where can I play old-school Factions instead?
Look for a server with monthly maps, real raiding and staff who actually play Factions. Our pick is EvadeCraft, which starts a new Factions map every month and pays out $550 in cash plus $1,000 in store credit every month.